Tuesday, December 11, 2007

Hell and damnation

Got your attention, didn't I?

A friend of mine and her husband are going through RCIA (instruction preparatory to joining the Catholic Church) at our parish. I enjoy chatting with her because many of the issues she is examining carefully are those I had to ponder as I was considering my own return to the Catholic Church in 2004. In one conversation, she mentioned that her husband has trouble with any hint of "hell and damnation". It's not uncommon for people to find it hard to understand that this doctrine is congruent with the all-surpassing love of God, but I've been thinking about it ever since.

It is true that we, as Christians, need to accept the truths of God that have been reliably revealed to us, regardless of the depth of our understanding. But that doesn't mean that they are always incapable of being at least partially understood. I think it is this way with the Final Judgment.

For me, the major discomfort with the thought of condemnation is any implication that it is arbitrary or somehow the spiteful comeuppance of an irritable God. This is, truly, not in harmony with the nature of God as we know him, he who is merciful, gracious and made of the very substance of love more real than we will ever know. So what is the place of eternal hell in the picture?
How long, O LORD? I cry for help
but you do not listen!
I cry out to you, "Violence!"
but you do not intervene. (Hab 1:2-3)
For me, I find tremendous hope in the fact that the evil and injustice I see in the world will absolutely not be allowed to stand. Torment, evil, vileness, malice, contempt, the snarl of envy and deceit, those who prey against the weak and helpless -- all this will be called to a halt when the Time comes. People will not be innocently entrapped nor caught accidentally in the backwash leading to everlasting death -- no, they will freely have chosen for or against love, goodwill and the kingdom of God. If they choose against, they will have made their move into the absence of God where all evil and hatred and the things unable to live in the light of Christ grow and flourish. Those loathsome things and the ones who choose them will be left outside the walls of God's city. And where God is not is no good thing.

But the people we love, what about them? There is lovableness in them. And even in those we don't love aren't constructed solely of evil; we see goodness, grace, and worthy objects of love. How can we deal with the fact that they may be condemned? How could this be?

Fear not. Eventually, each person will have the opportunity to freely and without handicap, constraint or lack of understanding answer the question of Jesus, "Will you be mine, or will you choose to have it your own way?" We will buy our own ticket for the train of our choice by accepting or spurning his invitation to ride in his railway car.

- - - - -

I'm finally writing these thoughts because I learned a young friend of mine is being caused considerable pain by being harassed at school. And then my daughters told me about the case of Megan Meier who committed suicide after being harassed by the (wait for it) mother of a former friend. I'm sorry, I'm a mild-mannered, Clark-Kentish kind of woman, but this sort of thing incites me to rage and thoughts of highly-inappropriate disproportionate illegal actions I would like to take. I am comforted by the realization that God hates cruelty and evil far more than I do, and he has a plan of action to take care of it.
For he will hide me in his shelter
in the day of trouble;
he will conceal me under the cover of his tent;
he will set me high on a rock. (Psalm 27:5)


Therese Z said...

Nice correlation of the "crying to Heaven for Violence" and the "I'd like to KILL that woman who teased that poor girl."

What I have to correlate is the feeling that when injustice strikes me, and I let it go in humility and charity, even humility and charity ground out unwillingly, that I don't immediately think "well, they'll get theirs when God judges them."

Find me a good Psalm or proverb along the lines of "God will take of unjust things - mind your own beeswax."

kc bob said...

I have had SO many conversation with Christian Universalists about Hell.. nice to see a different take on it than their's.

Generally I try to say some of the things that you say.. God is love.. He is good and He is just.. and He is trustable with eternity.. no one who knows Him needs to fear death.. there is hope in Jesus.. even for a thief on a cross.. all we need to do is call out to Him.. but there is the problem.. we have to do something.. sigh.. some don't even want to have to call out to Jesus as the thief did.

Happy Advent!

Therese Z said...

And look at the gift Jesus gave the repentant thief (St. Dismas, per pious tradition)!

KBob, what do Christian universalists say about hell? That nobody goes there? Or that there isn't such a place? That would be a little depressing to argue about - because you'd have to cite Scripture and I presume they don't hold that Scripture is inerrant...

kc bob said...

TZ: If you are really interested you might want to check out Brian's blog for info on Christian Universalism.

Therese Z said...

Thank you! He's certainly thinking hard isn't he? He isn't thinking with the mind of the Church, he's just thinking with his own mind, referring only to now, today, today's constructs, today's knowledge. But I'll give him credit for thinking. Hopefully, whatever is keeping him separated, isolated, on his own island, will change and he will learn that the Body of Christ is THE place to be.

Salome Ellen said...

This post is food for thought, but your new template, though pretty, gave me a headache. Have mercy on those of us with bifocals and other woes!



Sample Text

We are grateful ladies with a point of view and a sense of humor. Like-hearted people are welcome. Others, too.

For a glimpse at our lighter side, hop over to In Dwelling.

E-mail us.

Sample text

"There is no God who condones taking the life of an innocent human being. This much we know."

Pres. Barack Obama, Feb 5, 2009